We say we care about the health of the athletes who entertain us. But is it lip service? Our high schools still offer the sport of football. Americans became entranced by this sport in the middle 1960s. It really was more of an obscure sport before that. The problems of football have become well-documented. The sport marches on anyway.
No one would say they don't care about the health and safety of the athletes. They would suggest the opposite. But football marches on. We say we care and then we move on. Athletes who are done with their careers are easy to forget. There's always a "new crop" to draw our interest. Ah, the NFL "draft."
We can overlook how delicate the human body is. We can overlook the very real dangers in sports other than football. We are so safe as we sit in the bleachers or in front of our TV sets at home.
The baseball field really can be a dangerous place. I have read that if a baseball fan were to step onto the playing field, that fan would be surprised at how small a space it really is. The action happens fast there. Reflexes are everything. When a player reaches the age of about 33, he begins to lose his ideal reflexes.
"Beanings"
Baseball fans have to be aware of the problem of hit-by-pitch. They are probably aware that careers can be affected by this. We occasionally see a game highlight where a batter who has been "knocked down" charges the pitcher. Full-on brawls can erupt with umpires acting like they really do disapprove. But the sanctions are never enough to prevent pitchers from "brushing back" a hitter.
"Chin music," as it was described in Jim Bouton's "Ball Four."
The physical dangers to the batter are so great, I personally have felt a disincentive to keep following MLB. My reaction is much like with football where the dangers are more obvious.
You can thank your lucky stars you aren't out on the field being knocked down yourself or being knocked unconscious. Or ending up with CTE.
A reasonable person would have to be troubled by baseball. And yes I always run into naysayers who'd smile and say I'm getting carried away. This is especially true if I talk about high school football.
Baseball? I can look back to the uniquely heady days of the early Minnesota Twins. The young generation of boys was really drawn in. I'll frankly suggest it was a phenomenon like nothing we have seen since.
It was new
At the start of the 1960s we could have pinched ourselves to see if we were dreaming. The economy of sports had allowed our outpost of Minnesota to become viable for baseball and football at the highest level. All in the same year. People my age can still trot out names of the early Minnesota Twins.
Jim McRoberts and yours truly can still reminisce about Vic Power!
As I look back now, it is with a greatly heightened awareness about the physical dangers of baseball. The recent passing of Rich Rollins got me thinking about this. Rollins had a most concerning incident when he was with the Twins. Comes across as a nightmare really. He was playing a spring training game in 1963 when he was hit by a pitch thrown by Paul Foytack. Rollins had a broken jaw and would spend the first month of the season drinking all his meals through a straw.
Often with hit-by-pitch incidents, we can wonder if a player gets "gun shy" with the risk of having it happen again. So, I'm considering the case of Rollins' teammate Jimmie Hall along with Baltimore Oriole Paul Blair. I plucked these players out of my memory. I did no special research to identify them.
Patrick Reusse has described Hall as "a hero to the first young generation of Twins fans." Wholly true. Hall had power but was sleek in his physique unlike Harmon Killebrew or Bob Allison. Some Charisma, yes. He played center field. His rise in the Twins organization was the reason why we traded the popular Lenny Green. Hall offered more power than Green.
A fateful day for Hall and the Twins was May 27, 1964. The Twins and Angels were in the fifth inning of Game 1 of a doubleheader. Hall was hit by a pitch thrown by Bo Belinsky. The pitch struck Hall's cheek and he suffered a concussion. He returned to action a week later and now had a protective flap on the helmet. There was speculation after that, that Hall "lost something" as a player.
It was certainly not evident right away. His power did drop off but he kept his average up through 1965. He was even on the '65 All-Star team. But by the time of the '65 World Series against the Dodgers, he was being platooned in the lineup.
Outfielders are expected to deliver power. Also, the concern about the lefty-batting Hall was that he might be intimidated by left-handed pitchers. The Dodgers had two outstanding lefthanders in Sandy Koufax and Claude Osteen.
Fans and the media never reached a total consensus on how Hall might have gone into decline. But after '65 his career dipped steadily. I would have to suggest that his "beaning" played into that. Imagine being hit in the head with a fastball.
Let's consider Paul Blair of the Baltimore Orioles. He was with the Orioles when they were the prime post-season rival of our Twins. We're talking 1969-70. It was on May 31, 1970, that Blair was hit by a pitch thrown by Ken Tatum of the Angels. Blair suffered a broken nose and other facial fractures. He did manage to play ten more years, but he never hit over .280 through the rest of his career.
Speculation swirled as with our Jimmie Hall.
I should note about Rich Rollins that while he rebounded to play well in 1963, he had a premature decline. His hitting dropped off by the time we played in the '65 World Series. By 1969 he had fallen into total obscurity as a member of the expansion Seattle Pilots who would become the Brewers.
With the Pilots the former Twin third-sacker at least became a footnote in Bouton's "Ball Four." Bouton could be harsh in how he wrote about many players but he laid off Rollins.
Addendum: Yes, the rise of Jimmie Hall led to the trade of Lenny Green. Hall was white and Green was black. Let me emphasize here that the new young fans of the Minnesota Twins were 100 percent non-racist. I was there, I know. I know there could be a problem in places like Philadelphia. Green excelled in the Twins' very first year, plus he was known to be a great ambassador for the organization.
Vic Power was a player of color from Puerto Rico. He should have been promoted to the Yankees in the mid-'50s but he was considered the "wrong" type of black person for the team. He was flamboyant and had personality.
Twins fans welcomed Vic Power with open arms. He was the team MVP in 1962 when we finished second to those Yankees, just five games out.
- Brian Williams - morrios mn minnesota - bwilly73@yahoo.com